Skip to content
A Furniture Store Gem!A fantastic experience! Their selection was incredible, offering beautiful, high-quality pieces...
The staff was incredibly helpful and made the whole process easy. Highly recommend for anyone looking to furnish thei...
Read More Reviews At:

Consumer Choice

Shop the Consumer Choice collection at Gaylord Furniture (McKinney, TX) in Lancaster, PA. This curated collection highlights top-rated furniture picks across living room, bedroom, dining room, and more — pieces recognized for their combination of quality construction, everyday value, and on-trend style. If you're looking for furniture that has been vetted for comfort, durability, and customer satisfaction, the Consumer Choice collection is a great place to start. Whether you're furnishing a new home or refreshing a single room, these selections make shopping easier by narrowing the field to proven favorites. Browse sofas, bedroom sets, dining tables, accent pieces, and more from the collection. Visit our furniture showroom in Lancaster to see Consumer Choice pieces on display, or browse the full collection online. Our team is here to help you find the right pieces for your home. Delivery and flexible financing are available throughout the Lancaster, PA area. Financing options available.

Filters

Filter

Refine

view all

Type

Brand

AR Availability

Bed Size

Color

Consumer Assembly

Top Products

Group

Material

Manual

Power

Price

Product Video

Shipping

Style

Sub Brand

Lamp Type

Mirror Type

Dining Table Height

Product Theme

Bed Style

Shade

clear

Shape

Table Shape

Number of Doors

Number of Drawers

Piece Count

Number of Shelves

Seat Count

Collection

clear
$
$
Porter Dresser image Save 23% Save %
$1,286.40
$1,286.40 - $1,286.40
$1,286.40
$989.54
$989.54 - $989.54
$989.54

Porter Dresser

3D Available

The quality craftsmanship is clear to see. The classic design elements—including inlaid panels, antiqued hardware and bun feet—are easy to love. Sa...

View full details
$1,286.40
$1,286.40 - $1,286.40
$1,286.40
$989.54
$989.54 - $989.54
$989.54
Save 23% Save %
Porter Chest of Drawers image Save 23% Save %
$1,448.10
$1,448.10 - $1,448.10
$1,448.10
$1,113.92
$1,113.92 - $1,113.92
$1,113.92

Porter Chest of Drawers

3D Available

The quality craftsmanship is clear to see. The classic design elements—including antiqued hardware and bun feet—are easy to love. Satisfying your t...

View full details
$1,448.10
$1,448.10 - $1,448.10
$1,448.10
$1,113.92
$1,113.92 - $1,113.92
$1,113.92
Save 23% Save %
Pinnadel Counter Height Bar Stool image Save 23% Save %
$288.81
$288.81 - $288.81
$288.81
$222.16
$222.16 - $222.16
$222.16

Pinnadel Counter Height Bar Stool

3D Available

This striking counter height bar stool serves a sense of refinement without all the formality. A 360-degree spin element keeps you in the flow of c...

View full details
$288.81
$288.81 - $288.81
$288.81
$222.16
$222.16 - $222.16
$222.16
Save 23% Save %
Pinnadel Bar Height Bar Stool image Save 23% Save %
$288.81
$288.81 - $288.81
$288.81
$222.16
$222.16 - $222.16
$222.16

Pinnadel Bar Height Bar Stool

3D Available

This pub height bar stool serves a sense of refinement without all the formality. A 360-degree spin element keeps you in the flow of conversation, ...

View full details
$288.81
$288.81 - $288.81
$288.81
$222.16
$222.16 - $222.16
$222.16
Save 23% Save %
Noorbrook Table (Set of 3) image
Save 23% Save %
$482.30
$482.30 - $482.30
$482.30
$371.00
$371.00 - $371.00
$371.00

Noorbrook Table (Set of 3)

Introduce a handsome country feel in your living area with this casual occasional table set. Planked tops with a breadboard layup supported on cant...

View full details
$482.30
$482.30 - $482.30
$482.30
$371.00
$371.00 - $371.00
$371.00
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$2,391.66
$2,391.66 - $2,391.66
$2,391.66
$1,839.74
$1,839.74 - $1,839.74
$1,839.74

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Reclining Sofa

3D Available

It’s time to rethink the way you relax—and time to experience the joys of this power reclining sofa. Taking a fashion-forward approach to the art o...

View full details
$2,391.66
$2,391.66 - $2,391.66
$2,391.66
$1,839.74
$1,839.74 - $1,839.74
$1,839.74
Save 23% Save %
Next-Gen DuraPella Power Reclining Sofa image
Save 23% Save %
$2,985.35
$2,985.35 - $2,985.35
$2,985.35
$2,296.42
$2,296.42 - $2,296.42
$2,296.42

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Reclining Sofa

3D Available

This sleek, ultra-modern power reclining sofa with drop-down table has it all. With designer style and head-to-toe comfort, it has the upscale look...

View full details
$2,985.35
$2,985.35 - $2,985.35
$2,985.35
$2,296.42
$2,296.42 - $2,296.42
$2,296.42
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$2,338.88
$2,338.88 - $2,338.88
$2,338.88
$1,799.14
$1,799.14 - $1,799.14
$1,799.14

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Reclining Loveseat with Console

3D Available

It’s time to rethink the way you relax—and time to experience the joys of this power reclining loveseat. Taking a fashion-forward approach to the a...

View full details
$2,338.88
$2,338.88 - $2,338.88
$2,338.88
$1,799.14
$1,799.14 - $1,799.14
$1,799.14
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$2,338.88 - $2,932.57
$2,338.88 - $2,932.57
$2,338.88
$1,799.14 - $2,255.82
$1,799.14 - $2,255.82
$1,799.14

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Reclining Loveseat with Console

3D Available

It’s time to rethink the way you relax—and time to experience the joys of this power reclining loveseat. Taking a fashion-forward approach to the a...

View full details
$2,338.88 - $2,932.57
$2,338.88 - $2,932.57
$2,338.88
$1,799.14 - $2,255.82
$1,799.14 - $2,255.82
$1,799.14
Save up to 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$1,138.23
$1,138.23 - $1,138.23
$1,138.23
$875.56
$875.56 - $875.56
$875.56

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Recliner

3D Available

Stylish, adaptable and durable. Your living room is the central hub of your home—why settle for anything less? With this power recliner, you can ma...

View full details
$1,138.23
$1,138.23 - $1,138.23
$1,138.23
$875.56
$875.56 - $875.56
$875.56
Save 23% Save %
Next-Gen DuraPella Power Recliner image
Save 23% Save %
$1,987.99
$1,987.99 - $1,987.99
$1,987.99
$1,529.22
$1,529.22 - $1,529.22
$1,529.22

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Recliner

3D Available

It’s time to rethink the way you relax—and time to experience the joys of this power recliner. Taking a fashion-forward approach to the art of rela...

View full details
$1,987.99
$1,987.99 - $1,987.99
$1,987.99
$1,529.22
$1,529.22 - $1,529.22
$1,529.22
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$2,286.10
$2,286.10 - $2,286.10
$2,286.10
$1,758.54
$1,758.54 - $1,758.54
$1,758.54

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Recliner

3D Available

This sleek, ultra-modern power recliner has it all. With designer style and head-to-toe comfort, it has the upscale look of leather at a scaled-dow...

View full details
$2,286.10
$2,286.10 - $2,286.10
$2,286.10
$1,758.54
$1,758.54 - $1,758.54
$1,758.54
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,138.23 - $2,286.10
$1,138.23 - $2,286.10
$1,138.23
$875.56 - $1,758.54
$875.56 - $1,758.54
$875.56

Next-Gen DuraPella Power Recliner

3D Available

It’s time to rethink the way you relax—and time to experience the joys of this power recliner. Taking a fashion-forward approach to the art of rela...

View full details
$1,138.23 - $2,286.10
$1,138.23 - $2,286.10
$1,138.23
$875.56 - $1,758.54
$875.56 - $1,758.54
$875.56
Save up to 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$1,096.19
$1,096.19 - $1,096.19
$1,096.19
$843.22
$843.22 - $843.22
$843.22

Next-Gen Durapella Power Lift Recliner

This power lift recliner makes at-home lounging an effortlessly comfortable experience. Indulge in a full recline—its spacious seating area gives y...

View full details
$1,096.19
$1,096.19 - $1,096.19
$1,096.19
$843.22
$843.22 - $843.22
$843.22
Save 23% Save %
Nerviano Recliner image
Save 23% Save %
$459.19
$459.19 - $459.19
$459.19
$353.22
$353.22 - $353.22
$353.22

Nerviano Recliner

Indulge in comfort—while saving on space—with this zero wall recliner. This zero wall design means you only need a few inches of room between the b...

View full details
$459.19
$459.19 - $459.19
$459.19
$353.22
$353.22 - $353.22
$353.22
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Dining Server image
Save 23% Save %
$1,549.03
$1,549.03 - $1,549.03
$1,549.03
$1,191.56
$1,191.56 - $1,191.56
$1,191.56

Moriville Dining Server

3D Available

This dining room server might be simple at first sight, but a closer look reveals beauty in the details. With the plank-effect cabinet doors and ta...

View full details
$1,549.03
$1,549.03 - $1,549.03
$1,549.03
$1,191.56
$1,191.56 - $1,191.56
$1,191.56
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Dining Extension Table image
Save 23% Save %
$1,010.80
$1,010.80 - $1,010.80
$1,010.80
$777.54
$777.54 - $777.54
$777.54

Moriville Dining Extension Table

3D Available

This dining room extension table elevates the art of casual rustic style. Clean-lined, farmhouse profile is beautified with a distressed nutmeg fin...

View full details
$1,010.80
$1,010.80 - $1,010.80
$1,010.80
$777.54
$777.54 - $777.54
$777.54
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Dining Chair image
Save 23% Save %
$170.66
$170.66 - $170.66
$170.66
$131.28
$131.28 - $131.28
$131.28

Moriville Dining Chair

This upholstered dining chair elevates the art of casual rustic style. With a distressed nutmeg finish, antiqued nailhead trim and textured polyest...

View full details
$170.66
$170.66 - $170.66
$170.66
$131.28
$131.28 - $131.28
$131.28
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Dining Bench image
Save 23% Save %
$202.75
$202.75 - $202.75
$202.75
$155.96
$155.96 - $155.96
$155.96

Moriville Dining Bench

This upholstered dining bench elevates the art of casual rustic style. With a distressed nutmeg finish, antiqued nailhead trim and textured polyest...

View full details
$202.75
$202.75 - $202.75
$202.75
$155.96
$155.96 - $155.96
$155.96
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Counter Height Dining Extension Table image
Save 23% Save %
$1,180.01
$1,180.01 - $1,180.01
$1,180.01
$907.70
$907.70 - $907.70
$907.70

Moriville Counter Height Dining Extension Table

3D Available

This counter height dining table might be simple at first sight, but a closer look reveals beauty in the details. From the through-tenon pedestal b...

View full details
$1,180.01
$1,180.01 - $1,180.01
$1,180.01
$907.70
$907.70 - $907.70
$907.70
Save 23% Save %
Moriville Counter Height Dining Bench image
Save 23% Save %
$268.37
$268.37 - $268.37
$268.37
$206.44
$206.44 - $206.44
$206.44

Moriville Counter Height Dining Bench

This counter height upholstered bench might be simple at first sight, but a closer look reveals beauty in the details. With a distressed nutmeg fin...

View full details
$268.37
$268.37 - $268.37
$268.37
$206.44
$206.44 - $206.44
$206.44
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$1,521.78
$1,521.78 - $1,521.78
$1,521.78
$1,170.60
$1,170.60 - $1,170.60
$1,170.60

Midnight-Madness Oversized Chaise

3D Available

Wrapped in luxuriously soft jumbo corduroy, this oversized chaise takes cozy and inviting to a higher level. The sumptuous piece is perfect for unw...

View full details
$1,521.78
$1,521.78 - $1,521.78
$1,521.78
$1,170.60
$1,170.60 - $1,170.60
$1,170.60
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$454.97
$454.97 - $454.97
$454.97
$349.98
$349.98 - $349.98
$349.98

Midnight-Madness Oversized Accent Ottoman

3D Available

Wrapped in luxuriously soft jumbo corduroy, this oversized accent ottoman takes cozy and inviting to a higher level. The sumptuous piece is perfect...

View full details
$454.97
$454.97 - $454.97
$454.97
$349.98
$349.98 - $349.98
$349.98
Save 23% Save %
McGann Recliner image
Save 23% Save %
$660.48
$660.48 - $660.48
$660.48
$508.06
$508.06 - $508.06
$508.06

McGann Recliner

3D Available

Rock the cool look of leather and the warm feel of fabric with this rocker recliner. Sporting sumptuously thick cushioning, fashion-forward jumbo s...

View full details
$660.48
$660.48 - $660.48
$660.48
$508.06
$508.06 - $508.06
$508.06
Save 23% Save %

Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Consumer Choice collection?

Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at Gaylord Furniture (McKinney, TX) — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.

Why should I shop Consumer Choice?

If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture that have already won people over.

Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?

Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.

Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?

Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.

Can I see these items in person?

Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.

What if my item arrives damaged?

Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.

5 Stars
Top Rated
Delivery Available
Payment Options Available