Skip to content
A Furniture Store Gem!A fantastic experience! Their selection was incredible, offering beautiful, high-quality pieces...
The staff was incredibly helpful and made the whole process easy. Highly recommend for anyone looking to furnish thei...
Read More Reviews At:

Consumer Choice

Shop the Consumer Choice collection at Gaylord Furniture (McKinney, TX) in Lancaster, PA. This curated collection highlights top-rated furniture picks across living room, bedroom, dining room, and more — pieces recognized for their combination of quality construction, everyday value, and on-trend style. If you're looking for furniture that has been vetted for comfort, durability, and customer satisfaction, the Consumer Choice collection is a great place to start. Whether you're furnishing a new home or refreshing a single room, these selections make shopping easier by narrowing the field to proven favorites. Browse sofas, bedroom sets, dining tables, accent pieces, and more from the collection. Visit our furniture showroom in Lancaster to see Consumer Choice pieces on display, or browse the full collection online. Our team is here to help you find the right pieces for your home. Delivery and flexible financing are available throughout the Lancaster, PA area. Financing options available.

Filters

Filter

Refine

view all

Type

Brand

AR Availability

Bed Size

Color

Consumer Assembly

Top Products

Group

Material

Manual

Power

Price

Product Video

Shipping

clear

Style

Sub Brand

Mirror Type

Dining Table Height

Product Theme

Bed Style

Shade

Shape

Table Shape

Number of Doors

Number of Drawers

Number of Shelves

Seat Count

Collection

clear
$
$
Save 23% Save %
$829.01
$829.01 - $829.01
$829.01
$637.70
$637.70 - $637.70
$637.70

Watson Occasional Table Set

Showing off big-time with oversized tabletop space, this occasional table set serves up major contemporary style. Drawing from the beauty of clean-...

View full details
$829.01
$829.01 - $829.01
$829.01
$637.70
$637.70 - $637.70
$637.70
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$434.62
$434.62 - $434.62
$434.62
$334.32
$334.32 - $334.32
$334.32

Watson End Table Set

Drawing from the beauty of clean-lined mid-century design, this 2-piece square end table set feels right at home in today’s modern spaces. Oil-rubb...

View full details
$434.62
$434.62 - $434.62
$434.62
$334.32
$334.32 - $334.32
$334.32
Save 23% Save %
Watson Coffee Table image Save 23% Save %
$394.39
$394.39 - $394.39
$394.39
$303.38
$303.38 - $303.38
$303.38

Watson Coffee Table

Showing off big-time with oversized tabletop space, this rectangular coffee table serves up major contemporary style. Drawing from the beauty of cl...

View full details
$394.39
$394.39 - $394.39
$394.39
$303.38
$303.38 - $303.38
$303.38
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$490.67 - $730.18
$490.67 - $730.18
$490.67
$377.44 - $561.68
$377.44 - $561.68
$377.44

Valebeck End Table Set

To those with an eye for the best in rustic farmhouse living, this two-tone 2-piece end table set doubles up on charm. Designer touches include pla...

View full details
$490.67 - $730.18
$490.67 - $730.18
$490.67
$377.44 - $561.68
$377.44 - $561.68
$377.44
Save up to 23% Save %
Valebeck Dining Table image
Save 23% Save %
$1,143.53
$1,143.53 - $1,143.53
$1,143.53
$879.64
$879.64 - $879.64
$879.64

Valebeck Dining Table

3D Available

A high-style choice for casual spaces, this dining table serves up the best in rustic farmhouse living. Its two-tone distressed finish pairs a brow...

View full details
$1,143.53
$1,143.53 - $1,143.53
$1,143.53
$879.64
$879.64 - $879.64
$879.64
Save 23% Save %
Valebeck Dining Server image
Save 23% Save %
$1,346.28
$1,346.28 - $1,346.28
$1,346.28
$1,035.60
$1,035.60 - $1,035.60
$1,035.60

Valebeck Dining Server

3D Available

To those with an appetite for rustic farmhouse living, this server dishes out irresistible form and function. A pair of cabinet doors with mesh wir...

View full details
$1,346.28
$1,346.28 - $1,346.28
$1,346.28
$1,035.60
$1,035.60 - $1,035.60
$1,035.60
Save 23% Save %
Valebeck Dining Room Set image
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,320.05 - $3,983.46
$1,320.05 - $3,983.46
$1,320.05
$1,015.42 - $3,064.20
$1,015.42 - $3,064.20
$1,015.42

Valebeck Dining Room Set

This 5-piece dining set serves up the best in rustic farmhouse living. The extension dining table's two-tone distressed finish pairs a brown tablet...

View full details
$1,320.05 - $3,983.46
$1,320.05 - $3,983.46
$1,320.05
$1,015.42 - $3,064.20
$1,015.42 - $3,064.20
$1,015.42
Save up to 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$638.85 - $1,079.36
$638.85 - $1,079.36
$638.85
$491.42 - $830.28
$491.42 - $830.28
$491.42

Valebeck Counter Height Dining Table

3D Available

A high-style choice for smaller spaces, this counter height dining table serves up the best in rustic farmhouse living. Its two-tone finish pairs a...

View full details
$638.85 - $1,079.36
$638.85 - $1,079.36
$638.85
$491.42 - $830.28
$491.42 - $830.28
$491.42
Save up to 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,161.76 - $1,310.82
$1,161.76 - $1,310.82
$1,161.76
$893.66 - $1,008.32
$893.66 - $1,008.32
$893.66

Tyler Creek Table Set

Shabby chic with a hint of down home country. This occasional table set with textured black finish is the talk of today’s design world. Wood grain ...

View full details
$1,161.76 - $1,310.82
$1,161.76 - $1,310.82
$1,161.76
$893.66 - $1,008.32
$893.66 - $1,008.32
$893.66
Save up to 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,407.09 - $1,705.21
$1,407.09 - $1,705.21
$1,407.09
$1,082.38 - $1,311.70
$1,082.38 - $1,311.70
$1,082.38

Tyler Creek Occasional Table Set

Shabby chic with a hint of down home country. This occasional table set with textured black finish is all the talk of today’s design world. Wood gr...

View full details
$1,407.09 - $1,705.21
$1,407.09 - $1,705.21
$1,407.09
$1,082.38 - $1,311.70
$1,082.38 - $1,311.70
$1,082.38
Save up to 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$490.67 - $788.79
$490.67 - $788.79
$490.67
$377.44 - $606.76
$377.44 - $606.76
$377.44

Tyler Creek End Table Set

Shabby chic with a hint of down home country. This 2-piece rectangular end table with textured black finish is all the talk of today’s design world...

View full details
$490.67 - $788.79
$490.67 - $788.79
$490.67
$377.44 - $606.76
$377.44 - $606.76
$377.44
Save up to 23% Save %
Tyler Creek Dining Table image
Save 23% Save %
$876.62
$876.62 - $876.62
$876.62
$674.32
$674.32 - $674.32
$674.32

Tyler Creek Dining Table

3D Available

Invite your family into the heart of your home with this rectangular dining room table. Its tapered legs, in a beautifully textured black finish, p...

View full details
$876.62
$876.62 - $876.62
$876.62
$674.32
$674.32 - $674.32
$674.32
Save 23% Save %
Tyler Creek Dining Server image
Save 23% Save %
$1,277.74
$1,277.74 - $1,277.74
$1,277.74
$982.88
$982.88 - $982.88
$982.88

Tyler Creek Dining Server

3D Available

Invite your family into the heart of your home with this dining room server. Its beautifully textured black finish and timeworn planked oak top cre...

View full details
$1,277.74
$1,277.74 - $1,277.74
$1,277.74
$982.88
$982.88 - $982.88
$982.88
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,623.44 - $2,233.14
$1,623.44 - $2,233.14
$1,623.44
$1,248.80 - $1,717.80
$1,248.80 - $1,717.80
$1,248.80

Tyler Creek Dining Set

Set your sights on this dining set. The rectangular table, with six drawers for storing away smaller items, beautifully suits your storage needs. I...

View full details
$1,623.44 - $2,233.14
$1,623.44 - $2,233.14
$1,623.44
$1,248.80 - $1,717.80
$1,248.80 - $1,717.80
$1,248.80
Save up to 23% Save %
Tyler Creek Counter Height Dining Table image
Save 23% Save %
$1,042.91
$1,042.91 - $1,042.91
$1,042.91
$802.24
$802.24 - $802.24
$802.24

Tyler Creek Counter Height Dining Table

3D Available

Invite your family into the heart of your home with this rectangular counter height dining room table. A beautifully textured black finish and a ti...

View full details
$1,042.91
$1,042.91 - $1,042.91
$1,042.91
$802.24
$802.24 - $802.24
$802.24
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$1,923.90 - $2,364.39
$1,923.90 - $2,364.39
$1,923.90
$1,479.92 - $1,818.76
$1,479.92 - $1,818.76
$1,479.92

Tyler Creek Counter Height Dining Set

Set your sights on this counter height dining table set. The high-profile table beautifully suits your storage needs—its base includes two open she...

View full details
$1,923.90 - $2,364.39
$1,923.90 - $2,364.39
$1,923.90
$1,479.92 - $1,818.76
$1,479.92 - $1,818.76
$1,479.92
Save up to 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$1,087.09
$1,087.09 - $1,087.09
$1,087.09
$836.22
$836.22 - $836.22
$836.22

Tulen Reclining Sofa

3D Available

This reclining sofa puts the win in winning. Its waterfall back design and doubly plump pillow top arms team up with soft chenille fabric to go for...

View full details
$1,087.09
$1,087.09 - $1,087.09
$1,087.09
$836.22
$836.22 - $836.22
$836.22
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$1,002.46
$1,002.46 - $1,002.46
$1,002.46
$771.12
$771.12 - $771.12
$771.12

Tulen Reclining Loveseat

3D Available

This reclining loveseat puts the win in winning. Its waterfall back design and doubly plump pillow top arms team up with soft chenille fabric to go...

View full details
$1,002.46
$1,002.46 - $1,002.46
$1,002.46
$771.12
$771.12 - $771.12
$771.12
Save 23% Save %
Save 23% Save %
$660.48
$660.48 - $660.48
$660.48
$508.06
$508.06 - $508.06
$508.06

Tulen Recliner

3D Available

This rocker recliner puts the win in winning. Its waterfall back design and doubly plump pillow top arms team up with soft chenille fabric to go fo...

View full details
$660.48
$660.48 - $660.48
$660.48
$508.06
$508.06 - $508.06
$508.06
Save 23% Save %
Save up to 23% Save %
$2,089.54 - $2,750.02
$2,089.54 - $2,750.02
$2,089.54
$1,607.34 - $2,115.40
$1,607.34 - $2,115.40
$1,607.34

Tulen Living Room Set

This reclining sofa, loveseat and recliner set puts the win in winning. Its waterfall back design and doubly plump pillow top arms team up with sof...

View full details
$2,089.54 - $2,750.02
$2,089.54 - $2,750.02
$2,089.54
$1,607.34 - $2,115.40
$1,607.34 - $2,115.40
$1,607.34
Save up to 23% Save %
Trinell Youth Chest of Drawers image
Save 23% Save %
$555.72
$555.72 - $555.72
$555.72
$427.48
$427.48 - $427.48
$427.48

Trinell Youth Chest of Drawers

3D Available

Whether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this chest of drawers matches their authenticity. Its rustic finish, plank-style details and na...

View full details
$555.72
$555.72 - $555.72
$555.72
$427.48
$427.48 - $427.48
$427.48
Save 23% Save %
Trinell Youth Bed with 2 Storage Drawers image
Save up to 23% Save %
$853.29 - $1,203.36
$853.29 - $1,203.36
$853.29
$656.38 - $925.66
$656.38 - $925.66
$656.38

Trinell Youth Bed with 2 Storage Drawers

Whether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this twin panel bed with under bed storage matches their authenticity. Its rustic finish, plank...

View full details
$853.29 - $1,203.36
$853.29 - $1,203.36
$853.29
$656.38 - $925.66
$656.38 - $925.66
$656.38
Save up to 23% Save %
Trinell Youth Bed with 1 Large Storage Drawer image
Save 23% Save %
$1,091.04
$1,091.04 - $1,091.04
$1,091.04
$839.26
$839.26 - $839.26
$839.26

Trinell Youth Bed with 1 Large Storage Drawer

Whether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this twin bookcase bed with under bed storage matches their authenticity. Its rustic finish, pl...

View full details
$1,091.04
$1,091.04 - $1,091.04
$1,091.04
$839.26
$839.26 - $839.26
$839.26
Save 23% Save %
Trinell Youth Bed image
Save up to 23% Save %
$503.20 - $587.81
$503.20 - $587.81
$503.20
$387.08 - $452.16
$387.08 - $452.16
$387.08

Trinell Youth Bed

Whether she loves horses or he's a cowboy at heart, this full panel bed matches their authentic sense of style. Its rustic finish, plank details an...

View full details
$503.20 - $587.81
$503.20 - $587.81
$503.20
$387.08 - $452.16
$387.08 - $452.16
$387.08
Save up to 23% Save %

Consumer Choice — Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Consumer Choice collection?

Consumer Choice gathers the pieces our customers love most at Gaylord Furniture (McKinney, TX) — the styles that get chosen, reviewed well, and reordered again and again. Think of it as a shortcut to our proven favorites.

Why should I shop Consumer Choice?

If you want something dependable without combing through the entire catalog, this is a great place to start — it's a curated shortlist of best-sellers from Ashley Furniture that have already won people over.

Do you deliver Consumer Choice items?

Yes. We deliver throughout our local service area — see our shipping & delivery policy for timelines and coverage, or contact us for a quote.

Can I finance a Consumer Choice purchase?

Yes. We offer financing options on qualifying purchases, often with promotional low- or no-interest plans.

Can I see these items in person?

Many of our most popular pieces are on display in the showroom, though the floor selection rotates. Please contact us to confirm a specific item is available to view before you visit.

What if my item arrives damaged?

Inspect it at delivery, note any damage on the paperwork, take photos, and contact us right away. We'll arrange a repair, replacement, or return under our return policy.

5 Stars
Top Rated
Delivery Available
Payment Options Available